home.gif (2772 bytes)

Conference Info

Membership Info

What's New @ BAAM

behavioral resources

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 Small BAAM Logo

BAAM Science Lessons
Demonstration of the Effects of Verbal Stimulus Control

 

Demonstration of the Effects of Verbal Stimulus Control

or

The "Clever Hands" Effect

Verbal behavior buffs, try this in class. It shows the power of immediate verbal stimulus control over delayed control.

This is also an excellent demonstration of unconscious cueing or bias, showing how difficult it is for observers to avoid biasing an outcome despite trying.


Directions

Create a series of 20 to 30 "yes-no" questions to be presented verbally. Half should be very easy: "Does a triangle have three-sides?" Half should be so difficult or obscure that no one is likely know the answers: "Did the Baron of Merchiston invent logarithms?" Alternate the easy and hard questions. Tell the class to listen carefully and think about each question as it is asked, but then write either "yes" or "no" in response completely randomly, entirely irrespective of the content of the question, trying not to make a predictable pattern of "yes" or "no."

Grade the answers. You'll see about 50% correct for the hard questions and about 75% correct for the easy questions. All of this occurs despite the previous explicit instructions to the subjects to answer randomly. The results show how difficult it is, nearly impossible, for observers to avoid unconsciously biasing their responses. For "treatments" that claim to establish pointing-based communication in people who are non-verbal, such as "Facilitated Communication," "Rapid Prompting," and "Informative Pointing," the implications of this effect could not be more clear. It is unlikely that the communication aide or facilitator can simply decide or "will themselves" to avoid controlling the typed of the supposed "communicator."

Based on:

Wegner, D.W., Fuller, V.A., & Sparrow, B. (2003). Clever hands: Uncontrolled intelligence in facilitated communication. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 85, 5–19. (PDF)

Front page of Wegner's "Clever Hands" article